Meeting Abstract | 2021 ASCO Quality Care Symposium


Background: The successful conduct of cancer clinical trials hinges on the willingness of patients to participate. The rate of adult clinical trial participation has been regarded as being < 5%. However, national estimates of trial participation are nearly two decades old, and no evidence based on original data sources has been examined for many years. Moreover, studies about trial participation have focused solely on enrollment to treatment trials, which does not reflect the willingness of patients to contribute to other key elements of clinical research, such as quality of life or biorepository studies. We determined inclusive, contemporary estimates of clinical trial participation for adults with cancer using a national sample of data from 1,200 institutions. Methods: The data were from the Commission on Cancer (CoC), a consortium of cancer-related organizations providing accreditation for both academic and community cancer care facilities across the U.S. CoC enrollment data represent 70% of all cases of cancer diagnosed each year. Deidentified, institution-level aggregate counts of annual enrollment to treatment, biorepository, diagnostic, economic, genetic, prevention, quality of life, registry, and screening studies were examined. Overall, study-type estimates for the period 2013-2017 were estimated. Multiple imputation by chained equations was used to account for missing data, with summary estimates calculated separately by type of program (e.g., NCI-designated cancer programs) and pooled. Results: Across the entire U.S. system, the estimated participation rate to cancer treatment trials was 6.3%. Enrollment to treatment trials was highest at NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers (18.9%), while for community cancer programs (CCPs) and comprehensive CCPs, treatment trial rates were 4.4% and 3.6%, respectively. Nearly 1 in 7 patients participated in biorepository studies (13.4%), including 39.4% at NCI cancer centers. Patients participated in a wide variety of other study types, including registry (8.1%), prevention (6.4%), genetic (3.6%), quality of life (2.9%), economic (2.7%), diagnostic (2.7%), and screening studies (1.8%). At least 25.4% of adult cancer patients were estimated to participate in one or more cancer clinical research studies. Conclusions: In a first-time use of nationally representative enrollment data from the CoC, enrollment to cancer treatment trials was 6.3%, higher than historical estimates of < 5%. Patients participated in a diverse set of other study types, and taken together, at least one quarter of patients participated in a study. Contributions of adult patients with cancer to clinical research is much more comprehensive than previously understood.

© 2021 by American Society of Clinical Oncology

Research Sponsor:

Public Health Sciences Division of the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center


No companion articles


DOI: 10.1200/JCO.2020.39.28_suppl.74 Journal of Clinical Oncology 39, no. 28_suppl (October 01, 2021) 74-74.

Published online September 21, 2021.

ASCO Career Center